Casey Lake Manors Homes For Sale

Casey Lake Manors Realtor

What’s Your Home Worth? Discover your home or condo’s market value today—free, fast, and with no obligation.

Get Valuation

No statistics available for Casey Lake Manors.

No listings found directly in Casey Lake Manors. Showing listings from the surrounding city: Tampa.

5 listings found in Tampa. Page 1 of 421.

$400,000

7402 N 56TH ST, TAMPA

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of RS EQUITY SERVICE LLC

$4,600,000

4929 BAY WAY, TAMPA

BEACH PARK ISLE SUB

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of VANDERLEELIE & ASSOC.RE ESTATE

$850,000

DALE MABRY, TAMPA

UNPLATTED

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of COTTAGE REALTY INC

$1,100,000

5210 NEBRASKA, TAMPA

WITCHMERE

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

3,437 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of RE/MAX REALTY UNLIMITED

$140,000

5902 50TH, TAMPA

UNPLATTED

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of LESLIE WELLS REALTY, INC.

$4,900,000

9586 TROUTWATER, TAMPA

WHITE TROUT LAKE SUB

5 Beds / 4 Baths

5,119 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of ROBERT SLACK LLC

$1,550

17114 CARRINGTON PARK, TAMPA

JADE AT TAMPA PALMS

2 Beds / 2 Baths

1,032 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of U-HOME REALTY LLC

$60,000

15434 FLORIDA, TAMPA

LAKE GASS ESTATES

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

44,522 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of A.L. COMMERCIAL, INC.

$559,000

1022 SYLVIA LANE, TAMPA

HILLANDALE RESERVE PH 2 3

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of ESHENBAUGH LAND COMPANY

$525,000

406 ORLEANS, TAMPA

WATROUS REV MAP

2 Beds / 1 Baths

922 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of CENTURY 21 CIRCLE

$159,950

3424 DALE MABRY, TAMPA

N/A Beds / N/A Baths

Courtesy of CENTURY 21 CARIOTI

$449,000

8008 LA SERENA, TAMPA

LAGO VISTA UNIT 3

3 Beds / 2 Baths

1,534 Sq. Ft.

Courtesy of WHITE DIAMOND REALTY

Casey Lake Manors real estate

Casey Lake Manors, Tampa: Waterfront Living at Its Finest

Relevé’s Insights
“Nestled along the shimmering shores of Casey Lake, this hidden gem offers one of Tampa’s most coveted waterfront lifestyles without the premium price tag of South Tampa. Established in the 1970s, Casey Lake Manors has evolved into a boater’s paradise where neighbors become lifelong friends and sunset views come standard. With deepwater access to Tampa Bay’s boating circuit and an unbeatable Carrollwood location, this community delivers Florida waterfront living at its most authentic.”

Neighborhood Overview
Casey Lake Manors is a waterfront-centric community known for:
✔ Home Price Range: $650,000 – $1.4M (2024 waterfront premiums ≈ 35-50%)
✔ Architectural Styles:
1970s-80s Florida ranch homes (1,800-3,200 sq ft)
2000s rebuilds with coastal contemporary designs
Quirky mid-century modern time capsules
✔ Lot Features:
80% of homes have private docks (canal or lakefront)
Standard 80′ waterfront frontage
No bulkhead issues (community-maintained seawalls)
✔ Top Schools: Lake Magdalene Elementary (A), Adams Middle (A), Chamberlain High (IB Program)
✔ Community Perks:
Private boat ramp & kayak launch
Annual “Light Up the Lake” holiday event
Active fishing club with tournaments

Lifestyle & Amenities
🚤 Boater’s Paradise
Direct access to Lake Magdalene → Old Tampa Bay → Gulf of Mexico
No fixed bridges for sailboat owners
Community dock with 24/7 security cameras
🌅 Waterfront Living
Famous “blue hour” sunset views over Casey Lake
Lakeside picnic area with grills
Best fishing spots for largemouth bass (per FWC reports)
🏡 Carrollwood Convenience
4 minutes to Dale Mabry restaurants
8 minutes to Carrollwood Cultural Center
15 minutes to Tampa International Airport

2025 Market Insights
🏡 Current Waterfront Dynamics
Non-waterfront homes: $650K-$850K
Dockable canal homes: $875K-$1.1M
Direct lakefront: $1.2M+
Days on Market: 22 average (waterfront sells 3x faster)
📈 Why Buyers Choose Casey Lake Manors
Last affordable deepwater access in North Tampa
Zero rental restrictions (investor-friendly)
Proven appreciation: 68% over 5 years (2019-2024)
💡 Local Secrets
Best Blocks: Northshore Dr has widest canals
Hidden Value: Many older homes have “grandfathered” dock rights
Future Outlook: New seawall repairs planned for 2026

Why We’re the Lake Experts
With 11 waterfront sales here since 2021, we offer:
✅ Dock inspection specialists (we check pilings personally)
✅ Boat storage solutions (know all the best dry stack options)
✅ Water depth charts for serious boaters
Make Your Move
For waterfront buyers:
→ Boaters’ Package: Tide charts + marina discounts
→ Dock Valuation Guide: What makes a premium slip
→ Lake Lifestyle Preview: Spend a day with current residents

Final Thought: Casey Lake Manors proves you don’t need a Gulf-front budget to enjoy Tampa’s best waterfront living. Whether you’re a serious angler, weekend sailor, or just love waking up to water views, this community offers a rare blend of accessibility, character, and value that’s disappearing elsewhere in Tampa.