839 40TH, SARASOTA, FL 34234
$399,000
Beds: 2
Baths: 1 Full
Sq. Ft.: 831 Sq. Ft.
Year Built: 1951
Lot Size: 0.16 Acres
Garage: N/A
Pool: No
DOM: 38























































Property Overview
Status: Active
Property Type: Residential
MLS #: 4bec5b415c2941a2a98d558a94120cad
Subdivision: INDIAN BEACH HIGHLANDS
County: Sarasota
HOA Fee: N/A
Year Built: 1951
Construction: Block, Stucco
Foundation: Slab
Roof: Shingle
Cooling: Central Air, Wall/Window Unit(s)
Heating: Central
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water Source: Public
Zoning: RSF4
Tax Amount: $3,625.00 (2024)
Listed On: Dec 2, 2025
Description
Welcome to 839 40th Street, located west of the trail in Sarasota's desirable Indian Beach Sapphire Shores/Museum District. This charming home is just steps away from a picturesque neighborhood beach along Sarasota Bay, renowned for its breathtaking sunsets. The neighborhood also features three water access points, a lovely park, a playground, and a dog park, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy. Tucked behind a lush, manicured garden filled with native Florida-friendly plants, you'll discover a peaceful secret garden oasis that invites you to unwind. This delightful two- bedroom, one-bathroom home features a second bedroom with its own separate entrance, providing endless possibilities for utilizing the space. The home beautifully blends historic charm, such as arched doorways and a built-in dresser, with modern upgrades, including stunning river rock granite countertops, travertine tile floors, and an efficient Rinnai instant gas water heater. The thoughtfully designed kitchen offers ample counter space, making it ideal for entertaining, while abundant natural light creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Each window is adorned with tasteful, matching wooden blinds, adding a cozy and polished feel throughout. For those who enjoy outdoor living, this home delivers with two screened-in porches and two open patios surrounded by tropical beauty (including a mature, fruiting grapefruit tree), providing a serene and private escape. Picture starting your day enjoying a cup of coffee on the back porch and winding down your evening with a glass of wine in the front garden, observing the vibrant butterflies and Florida birds, including the occasional visits from friendly neighborhood peacocks strolling by with their young. Additionally, the fully fenced backyard, complete with a 10-foot gate, makes storing a boat or RV effortless. This home boasts a proven Airbnb history, having achieved Super Host status, a Customer Favorite badge, and a perfect 5-star rating over its nine successful years. It’s conveniently located just minutes from Jungle Gardens, SRQ Airport, the Ringling Museum, Asolo Repertory Theatre, the Van Wezel Performing Arts Center, the Ringling College of Art and Design, the University of South Florida Sarasota campus, New College of Florida, and Sarasota’s vibrant downtown and award-winning beaches. Plus, it’s within walking distance of Bay Haven School of Basics Plus, one of the top elementary schools in Sarasota. This well-maintained, move-in-ready home is a rare find, offering an exceptional combination of charm, privacy, and a fantastic lifestyle in an idyllic setting full of Old Florida charm. With sturdy all-block construction and a history free from water intrusion or hurricane damage, you can enjoy peace of mind and lasting security. (This home is not in a hurricane flood zone.) If you’re searching for a quintessential Florida home located in a historical neighborhood on Sarasota Bay, surrounded by friendly neighbors and close to all that Sarasota has to offer, your search ends here. Don’t let this opportunity slip away. Schedule a showing today!
Exterior Features
Dog Run, Garden
Directions
US41 North to Myrtle. West on Myrtle to Chapel Dr. North on Chapel and it intersects with 40th St. go to 839, almost dead ahead on the North side of the road.
School Information
Elementary: Bay Haven Sch of Basics Plus Elementary
Middle: N/A
High: N/A
Location
Get Directions View on Google MapsMortgage Estimator
*Estimate includes Principal & Interest (P&I) only. It does not include taxes, insurance, HOA fees, or PMI. Rates and payments may vary. Consult a lender for accurate figures.
Listing Information
Provided Courtesy of:
PREFERRED SHORE LLC
Listing Agent: Ian Shannon
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Information provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Data last updated: January 28, 2026, 1:45 pm UTC
MLS Source: Stellar MLS Copyright © 2026
Similar Active Listings Nearby

1211 BAY PALM, INDIAN ROCKS BEACH
INDIAN BEACH RE-REVISED 1ST ADD
2 Beds / 1 Baths
900 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY PORTFOLIO COLLECTION

19725 GULF, INDIAN SHORES
SEA CLUB OF INDIAN SHORES CONDO
1 Beds / 1 Baths
875 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

19417 GULF, INDIAN ROCKS BEACH
BAREFOOT BEACH RESORT OF INDIAN SHORES
2 Beds / 1 Baths
950 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of PLUMLEE GULF BEACH REALTY
Similar Recently Sold Listings Nearby

8608 INDIAN RIDGE, LAKELAND
INDIAN RIDGE
3 Beds / 2 Baths
924 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC

133 COURT, TITUSVILLE
INDIAN RIVER SHORES SEC A
2 Beds / 2 Baths
902 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of LPT REALTY, LLC

7968 APACHE, LAKELAND
INDIAN HEIGHTS PH 02
3 Beds / 2 Baths
972 Sq. Ft.
Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY SMART
